How to Reheat Little Caesars Pizza in Different Ways

Pizza is loved by many people and no party is complete without it. Especially Little Caesars pizza, it has a great taste and crispier crust. But it happens that the Little Caesars pizza has cooled down before you started eating it. In this case, you need to warm it up. But how to reheat Little Caesar’s pizza without losing its unique flavor?

How to Reheat Little Caesars Pizza and Not to Spoil It

How to Reheat Little Caesars Pizza in the Oven?

It should be noted that this will be the best way because it is in the oven that the entire pizza will not lose its properties, will not be over-dried, and will not have a specific taste of warmed food.

The main secret is not to set too high temperatures, otherwise the pizza will start cooking further and as a result, it may simply burn.

Simple steps to reheat Little Caesars pizza in the oven without aluminum foil

Step 1: Start with regular oven reheating for 400 degrees Fahrenheit, ideally 350.

Step 2: Take a baking sheet or a pizza stone, (the second option is better), and place it in the oven for 15 minutes so that it heats up, so you can evenly and quickly reheat the pizza so that it does not burn.

Step 3: Place your Caesar pizza on a baking sheet or a pizza stone and place it carefully in the oven, do not forget to close the oven door so as not to release heat.

Step 4: Preheat the Little Caesar’s pizza for 10 minutes at the same temperature as at the beginning, constantly monitor the condition of the pizza, and do not let it burn.

Step 5: If you want a super-crispy crust with garlic bread, you can hold the bird for up to 15 minutes, but then show increased attention.

Step 6: As soon as you are satisfied with the temperature of the Little Caesars, its condition, and crusts, take it out of the oven and cover plastic wrap.

Let it stand for 2 minutes in the open air to cool down, this is done in order not to get burned while eating. By the way, if you have your pizza not sliced, use these tips from How to Cut a Pizza without a Pizza Cutter: Easy Tips.

A pizza slice on a pizza stone

How to Reheat Little Caesars Pizza in a Toaster Oven

Another convenient way to reheat pizza is considered a toaster oven. The only negative is the size.

To reheat pizza, you will have to cut it into a few slices and reheat each slice of pizza separately. It will take longer, but this way you will get a crisp, fresh crust. And most importantly, a warm pizza.

Moving away from the main topic, we hope your pizza didn’t get cold because of a long delivery time. In my opinion, this is the deciding factor of whether or not to tip the delivery guy. How much do you think pizza delivery workers make?

Reheat Little Caesars pizza in the toaster oven

Step 1: Preheat your toaster. If he has a temperature meter, we recommend setting the temperature to 350 degrees Fahrenheit, if not, then warm up to the maximum.

Step 2: Put the pizza stone or oven pan inside the toaster oven and heat it for 15 minutes.

Step 3: Next, place a slice of pizza on the surface of the stone or oven pan to fit into your toaster oven. If the size allows, reheat several slices at once or half of the Little Caesars.

Step 4: Preheat the Little Caesars in the toaster for ten minutes, no more, otherwise the pizza will burn.

Step 5: Take the pizza out of the toaster oven and put it on a serving dish, just let it cool down for a couple of minutes before eating so as not to get burned.

Two pizza slices on an toaster grid

How to Reheat Little Caesars Pizza in the Microwave Oven

Less popular and effective, but perhaps one of the fastest ways to warm up pizza.

In the microwave safe plate, as a rule, all the smells of food are very strongly mixed, so a preheated pizza may have a specific taste. But a lot depends on which kind of microwaves you use.

Also in the microwave-safe plate it is very difficult to achieve a good crispy cheese crust or the usual crispy pizza or taste pizza toppings.

Microwaving a pizza slice

Reheat Little Caesars pizza in the microwave oven

Step 1: Put the cold pizza on a special plate for the microwave.

Step 2: to prevent the Little Caesar’s pizza from getting too dry, you need humidity in the microwaves pan, to do this, take a microwave-safe cup of water and put it in a microwave oven.

Step 3: Put the Little Caesar’s pizza on medium power in the microwaves pan for 1.5 minutes

Step 4: after you have taken out the Little Caesar’s pizza, be sure to lubricate it with olive oil, so you will preserve the structure of the whole pizza. You can serve it on the table.

How to Reheat Little Caesars Pizza on the Stovetop

The most dangerous way to heat Little Caesar’s pizza is on the stove or open fire. Here you can’t regulate the temperature and just burn it down. But if you have decided to take this step, then follow these instructions.

Pepperoni pizza on a skillet

Reheating Little Caesars pizza on the stovetop

Step 1: It is best to take a cast iron skillet pan slightly larger than the size of a frozen Little Caesars pizza and put it on medium heat on the stove.

Step 2: Do not heat the whole Little Caesars pizzas, it is more difficult to regulate the process. Cut the pizza slice and heat one or two pieces for two minutes under a closed lid preliminarily stovetop reheating.

Step 3: After that, in order not to over-dry the pizza slice, pour a few drops water on the bottom of the pan, but make sure that the water does not get on the pizza itself, for this we took a large-diameter frying pan.

Step 4: Close the lid again and heat until steam appears and the cheese melts.

Step 5: Remove a reheating multiple slices from the pan and serve in deep dish, then do the same with the rest of the pizza slice.

To recap, let’s watch a video by Food Review UK about the most popular ways to reheat any pizza:

How to Store Little Caesars Pizza Leftovers

Like all other products, if stored incorrectly, classic pizzas will also last a shorter period of time. If you want your pizza to stay fresh, you should keep it in the refrigerator. It is important to place the leftover pizza in a tightly closed container.

Thus, you will protect your leftover pizza from drying out, as well as from excessive moisture and other contaminants.

In addition, it is recommended to cover the Little Caesars food items with plastic wrap or aluminum foil when it is in the refrigerator. If storage is to be short, it is acceptable to leave the pizza directly in the box, and to save space in your fridge, use this method: Easy to Store Leftovers in the Fridge.

If you want to store pizza for a long time, you have to freeze it. But it is important to use sealed freezer containers. With such storage, the pizza will retain its taste, and its shelf life will be much longer.

  1. Freeze the remaining pizza in foil bags or with a lock (frozen pizza holds the structure better). Be sure to freeze the slices in one layer so that they do not stick together.
  2. Wrap the frozen pizza crust in foil. If you are a crunchy crust lover, this is a KEY step to preserving the texture of the crust.
  3. Bake at 375 degrees for 12-15 minutes, depending on the size of the slice.

It’s worth the time. Much better than in a microwave oven. Crust every time.

Two slices of pizza on a plate

Can you put a Caesar box in the oven?

Yes, you can put the “Little Caesar” box in the oven. The box is made of corrugated cardboard, which can be safely used in the oven if it does not touch the heating element. Preheat the oven to the temperature indicated on the box, then place the pizza set in it. The pizza will be cooked evenly thanks to the ventilation holes built into the box. If you’re still in doubt about putting the box in the oven, check out Can You Put A Pizza Box In The Oven? 4 Alternatives To Cardboard Method.

Chapter FAQ

How long should I Put a Little Caesars pizza in the oven?

A small Caesar pizza is baked for an average of 10 minutes. If you want a super-taste crust, then you can hold the pizza a Little Further, about 15 minutes, but the main thing is not to overdo it so that the pizza does not burn.

What is the best way to reheat pizza?

It is best to reheating pizza in the oven, so it will not lose all its properties. You will be able to keep the crisp texture of the base and crust.
The taste of pizza will not mix with the taste of other products. In addition, this method is fast and not energy-consuming. In just 20 minutes you will be able to bring your pizza back to its former form.

How long should you put Little Caesars pizza in the microwave?

It’s not worth heating pizza in a microwave oven for a long time, because the air will simply dry out all the moisture, the taste crust will disappear, and the cheese crust will harden.
The optimal time is 1.5-2 minutes.

How do you reheat Little Caesars air fryer?

Step 1: Preheat it to 180°C
Step 2: Pre-sprinkle the Caesars deep dish pizza slices with olive oil (so the crust will become crispy again).
Step 3: Then pour a couple of teaspoons of water under the main compartment of the air fryer so that a little steam is formed during heating (so the pizza will not dry out).
Step 4: Place the pizza slices in the air fryer and make sure they don’t overlap each other.
Step 5: Cook pizza for about four minutes.
Voila — the pizza is fresh and juicy in air fryer, as if only from the oven again!

Pizza slice in an air fryer


It is very important to reheat Little Caesars pizza correctly so that it does not lose all its properties, does not lose its crispy crust, crispy edges, crispy bottom.

There are various methods of heating pizza, which we have told you about today, we hope that you have found the most convenient for you. The main thing to remember is not to use too low heat in the oven, but do not take high ones either.

Constantly make sure that the toppings and cheese do not burn or dry up. If you heat the pizza on an open fire, follow only the medium high heat.

Little Caesars deep dish pizza

Malena Miller

“If you love pizza as much as I do, then I think we can get along.”

I run this blog and I love making pizza. I have 150 pizza recipes. I want to share with you the secrets of cooking pizza

Leave a Comment